Editor's Note

The FOI Advocate is a compendium of ideas, edited story excerpts and other materials from a variety of Web sites, as well as original concepts and analysis. When the information comes directly from another source, it will be attributed and a link will be provided whenever possible. The blog relies on the accuracy and integrity of the original sources cited. We will correct errors and inaccuracies when we become aware of them.

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Effort to Revise West Virginia's Public Records Law Underway

West Virginia state lawmakers introduced legislation that would apply the Freedom of Information Act to any record prepared or received by a public office or official if its content or context relates to the public's business.

The effort to revise the state's public records law comes after the state Supreme Court blocked the release of a justice's e-mails with a coal company executive.

For more, click here.

University of Illinois Log Shows Ten Incidents of Attempted Outside Influence in Admissions Process This Year

After it was revealed that the University of Illinois had a secret admissions system that allowed the politically powerful to influence admissions decisions, the admissions staff is now required to log incidents of outside parties trying to insert themselves into the admissions process.

This year, the U of I admissions staff have logged 10 such incidents, the majority of which The Chicago Tribune describes as "relatively benign."

Admissions officers can enter comments into a password-protected Web site at their discretion, but cannot access the information. University employees risk being fired and university trustees risk being removed by the board of the governor if they interfere.

Click here for more.

ASNE Local Heroes Sunshine Week Contest Deadline Fast Approaching

The ASNE Local Heroes Sunshine Week contest deadline is Friday, February 26.

Nominate someone in your area who made a difference last year by fighting to make public institutions more open and accessible.

The first-place winner will be honored at the 2010 ASNE Convention in Washington, DC. The second- and third- place winners will receive $500 and $250, respectively.

The nomination form is available here.

Knight FOI Fund Awards its First Funds

With the newly created Knight FOI Fund, the National Freedom of Information Coalition is helping Florida citizens seek answers to important questions of FOI law, including the scope of public access to economic development documents in Sarasota and whether handwritten notes used by a government official during a public meeting are subject to disclosure.

The Knight FOI Fund provides up-front costs such as court costs, filing fees, depositions, and initial consulting fees for FOI cases that would otherwise go unfiled. The economic crisis and the evolution of the news media revealed declining levels in FOI advocacy, which the Knight FOI Fund seeks to rectify. Applications for grants come from NFOIC member coalitions and are vetted by the NFOIC's Litigation Committee.

For more information, click here.

New Study Shows Online Open Government Efforts Drive Trust in Government

ForeSee Results conducted a quantitative assessment of online open government efforts by surveying more than 36,000 citizens on their reactions to 14 federal government Web sites. Researchers asked questions relating to how thoroughly the sites disclosed information about the agency, how quickly information was available online, and how accessible that information was on the sites. The answers then generated a transparency score.

The top-ranked agencies included the Agriculture Department's Center for Nutrition Policy and Promotion, the Health and Human Service Department's National Mental Health Information Center, the State Department's Bureau of Consular Affairs, and the main site of the General Services Administration.

For more information, click here.

Police Disciplinary Records Are Public Records in Columbia, Missouri

Boone County, Missouri Circuit Judge Kevin Crane declared the disciplinary records of a police officer open to the public under the city open records law adopted in July 2009 with the Citizens Police Review Board.

The ruling stems from a January 19 request made by The Columbia Tribune over an accusation that officers beat and shocked a man three times with a Taser during a December 2006 traffic stop. The Columbia police custodian of records located 97 pages of documents and eight disks of video responsive to the request. The Columbia Police Officers Association had tried to block the disclosure of disciplinary records.

For more, click here.

Illinois Lawmakers Seek to Undo Last Year's FOI Progress

Last year, Illinois lawmakers strengthened the state's freedom of information laws. This year, there are already more than six proposals to undo some of last year's progress.

The State Journal-Register reports the amendments include increasing the amount of money agencies can charge for public records to making attorneys' fees awards optional in cases where the requester prevails.

Two bills already passed limit public access, including one to create an online database to locate buried bodies, which is exempt from public disclosure, and one that bars disclosure of the evaluations of teachers, administrators, and superintendents.

Read more about it here.

Now Following Robert Gibbs on Twitter

White House spokesman Robert Gibbs joined Twitter last week. Gibbs said he'll "ask the lawyers" if his tweets are subject to the Presidential Records Act of 1978.

For more on the 140-character tweets of the press secretary, click here.



2009 Polk Award Winners

Long Island University announced its 13 George Polk Awards for 2009. A number of the recipients appear to have used FOIA and state open records laws in their reporting, including:
  • The Bloomberg News team of Mark Pittman, Bob Ivry, Alison Fitzgerald and Craig Torres for their work to open the Federal Reserve Board's books on the bailout;
  • Raquel Rutledge of The Journal Sentinel for investigating the fraud, waste, and criminal activity tied to the $350 million Wisconsin child-care system;
  • George Pawlaczyk and Beth Hundsdorfer of The News-Democrat for an investigative series exposing cruel conditions in an Illinois "supermax" prison;
  • A "60 Minutes" team of Steve Kroft and Leslie Cockburn for a segment detailing Wall Street's influence in speculative oil transactions;
  • Kathy Chu of USA Today for a series showing how banks and credit-card issuers used unscrupulous practices and fees to gauge billions from customers;
  • Charlie Reed, Kevin Baron and Leo Shane III of the independent military newspaper Stars and Strips for exposing the Pentagon's secret use of a PR company to steer reporters to "positive" coverage of the war in Afghanistan;
  • David Grann of The New Yorker for an investigative report challenging the evidence against Cameron Todd Willingham, who was executed in 2004 after being convicted of setting a fire that killed his three young daughters;
  • Abraham Lustgarten of ProPublica for investigating the potentially carcinogenic effects of hydraulic fracturing, a natural gas drilling process.
For more about the Polk Award winners, click here.

Ugandan Ruling Shows Difficulty in Establishing Freedom of Information in Sub-Saharan Africa

A Ugandan judge has ruled that reporters from Uganda's leading independent newspaper had not proved there was public benefit of disclosing certified copies of oil exploitation agreements. The journalists, along with the Open Society Institute's East Africa Initiative and Human Rights Network Uganda say they are considering an appeal of the ruling.

The journalists had argued the information was of interest to Ugandans seeking to hold the government and its partners accountable for multinational oil deals.

The ruling comes ahead of the African Regional Conference on the Right of Access to Information, an event featuring media leaders, press freedom advocates, officials, and former U.S. President Jimmy Carter.

For more information, click here.

South Carolina County Council May Have Violated Public Meetings Laws Conducting Business Via E-mail

In a three-part series, TheState.com reports that Horry County, South Carolina council members have repeatedly conducted business via e-mail, without a quorum, and out of the public's view. The Sun News obtained 1,348 pages of e-mails sent between January 2009 and January 2010, which reveal that the council may have violated the state's Freedom of Information Act by having conversations that should have taken place in a public meeting.

For more, click here.


Video and Reports of Former Utah State Senator's DUI Arrest to be Public

The Utah State Records Committee will release the three-hour long dash-cam video of former Utah state Sen. Sheldon Killpack's arrest for allegedly driving drunk. They will also release the Utah Highway Patrol's incident report. However, the release of the public records could be delayed by up to a month as the records committee has five days to sign an order stating its decision, and the Department of Public Safety has 30 days within which to appeal to the district court.

The Salt Lake Tribune reports that Killpack was stopped at 12:17 a.m. on January 15 and failed field sobriety tests. After Killpack refused a Breathalyzer test, a blood draw showed his blood-alcohol content at 0.11, which is above the legal limit of 0.08. Killpack resigned his political office the next day, and was charged with DUI and failure to signal.

For more information, click here.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Transparency or Financial Stability? The Arguments in Bloomberg v. Fed

The New York Times brings this fascinating account of the legal wranglings of Bloomberg News against the Fed for information pertaining to the Bailout. Described as a "principled grudge match," the feud over the financial news giant's FOIA requests has the Fed arguing that the information sought could cause stigmatization of certain banks, potentially bank runs, and could jeopardize the government's efforts to stabilize the economy, while Bloomberg argues it is seeking transparency in order to fulfill its watchdog role.

Idaho House Committee Considers Hunter Identity Protection Bill

Idaho's House Resources and Conservation Committee is considering a bill to protect the identity of wolf hunters who kill a wolf in the state.

IdahoReporter.com says the issue arose after wolves were de-listed under the Endangered Species Act. During a wolf hunt, anyone who killed a wolf was required to report it to the state's Department of Fish and Game in order to keep an accurate quota measurement. The kill reports were obtained by public records requests, and the names of the hunters were posted on the Internet.

For more on why critics say the privacy bill is a violation of freedom of speech and information, click here.

Washington Senate Votes to Make Voter Petitions Public Records

Washington Senators voted 28-20 to make voter petitions public records, including the names and addresses of people who sign initiatives and referenda.

In January, the U.S. Supreme Court said it will decide whether the people who signed Referendum 71 petitions should have their names publicly disclosed. Referendum 71 sought to overturn an expanded gay rights law.

For more about the bill, click here.

Editorial: "Public Records are Public Records"

Recent assaults on police officers have spawned proposed bills in the Washington legislature that would prohibit a law enforcement officer's month and year of birth and official photograph from being disclosed to the public, although the news media would still have access to it.

The Spokesman-Review editorializes that such a strategy is an unacceptable precedent and that the media should not have selective privileges. Instead, public records should remain public records.

For more, click here.

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Mexico Tries to Weaken its Transparency Law

Mexico's Interior Department has made suggestions to weaken the country's Law of Access to Public Information, which has been in force since 2002.

The Interior Department has proposed changes that would allow government offices to refuse to hand over data or to turn to the courts if they believe a request affects national security, defense, foreign relations, the economy, the money supply, or if it threatens "the life, security, or health of any person."

For more about the consequences of the so-called reform effort, click here.

Critics Say Using Confidential Informants Compromises Judicial System

Critics of the government's use of confidential informants are calling for more safeguards and guidelines to establish accountability against the secrecy of having thousands of informants on the government payroll. Despite guidelines established by the DOJ and the FBI, a 2005 Inspector General report shows that in 85% of the cases reviewed, the guidelines weren't followed.

Loyola Law School professor Alexandra Natapoff has authored a news book, Snitching, in which she says informants commit all sorts of crimes that compromise the judicial system and betray the national integrity.

Read more here.

Examples of Information Obtained Using FOIA

AnnArbor.com has compiled news stories that were based on FOIA requests, including thousands of 9/11 photos obtained by an ABC News reporter who was reading the Federal Register. The list also includes a status update on several pending FOIA requests.

Check it out here.

Washington Considers Removing Officials' Photographs from Public Records

In the wake of the deaths of four Lakewood, Washington police officers, the state's House and Ways and Means Committee voted to remove from public records photographs and birth dates of police, court and corrections employees.

Newspaper representatives say the bill would make it harder for the press not only to investigate where tax money goes and what lies in officials' pasts, but also to get images from the cameras that record police traffic stops or violent incidents inside jails or prisons.

Read more here.